Long Bay is one of Myrtle Beach’s most dynamic and up-and-coming neighborhoods, tucked between the sparkling Atlantic and lush green golf courses. While it’s known for its laid-back charm and picturesque streets, Long Bay has quietly evolved into a culinary haven. Whether you’re seeking mouthwatering seafood, cozy bakeries, or inventive food trucks, there’s a table—and flavor—waiting for you. Follow along as I dish out my favorite spots, must-try dishes, and neighborhood food traditions that make Long Bay a true delight for locals and visitors alike.
The Heart of Long Bay: Where Foodies Gather
The food scene here clusters along Shore Drive and Lake Arrowhead Road, with both mainstays and newcomers serving a mix of Southern staples, international flavors, and unique creations.
Can’t-Miss Restaurants on Shore Drive
- Bimini’s Oyster Bar & Seafood Cafe (930 Lake Arrowhead Rd.)
You haven’t truly eaten in Long Bay until you’ve pulled up a bar stool at Bimini’s. This decades-old institution is where locals treat themselves to Lowcountry boils, plump peel-and-eat shrimp, and, of course, legendary raw oysters. The fried seafood baskets are unbeatable, and the laid-back tiki bar vibe makes it a favorite for friends and families. Prices are moderate, and happy hour is a local ritual.
- Ocean Annie’s Beach Bar (9550 Shore Dr.)
Just steps from the beach, Ocean Annie’s is the embodiment of Myrtle Beach’s sun-and-fun spirit. Known for live music, potent tropical drinks, and crowd-pleasing favorites like fish tacos and burgers, it’s the spot to sip a piña colada as you gaze at the waves. The food is casual and affordable, and there’s no better place to end a beach day.
- Harry the Potter’s BBQ Shack (9831 Highway 17 N., near Shore Dr. intersection)
A smoky, mouthwatering stop for anyone craving genuine Carolina barbecue. Platefuls of pulled pork, slow-smoked brisket, and all the fixins’ draw raves, especially on weekends when local musicians play. Portions are generous and prices easy on the wallet.
International Eats: The World on a Plate
Long Bay’s food scene isn’t just about Southern classics—it’s impressively global.
- Fiesta Mexicana (9616 N. Kings Hwy.)
Just off Lake Arrowhead Rd., Fiesta Mexicana serves up authentic, boldly flavored Mexican cuisine. Locals crave their sizzling fajitas, cheesy enchiladas, and hand-shaken margaritas. It’s fun, vibrant, and reasonably priced—a great choice for group dinners or family outings.
- Romano’s Italian Restaurant (9712 N. Kings Hwy.)
Tucked in a charming strip along Highway 17, Romano’s is a go-to for hearty pasta, wood-fired pizza, and impossibly creamy tiramisu. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, making it perfect for date night or a relaxed meal with friends. Prices range from affordable to moderate, and the garlic knots alone are worth the stop!
Sweet Spots and Bakeries
Long Bay has its own way of satisfying your sweet tooth, from fresh pastries to dream-worthy desserts.
- Pink Pineapple Bakery (9703 N. Kings Hwy.)
A true hidden gem beloved by locals, Pink Pineapple dazzles with aromatic cinnamon rolls, flaky croissants, and gorgeous layer cakes. Their coconut cream pie? Absolutely unmissable. Warm, welcoming staff add to the charm, and their goodies are reasonably priced—indulge yourself!
- Café de Paris (9636 N. Kings Hwy.)
Swing by for French pastries, buttery quiches, and strong espresso. This artful little café transports you to Europe with every bite. It’s perfect for a mid-morning coffee date or a leisurely afternoon break. Prices are moderate and well worth the authentic flavors.
Food Trucks and Casual Eats
Part of Long Bay’s magic is its vibrant street food scene—keep an eye out for these rotating favorites at local events and beach gatherings.
- Murphy’s Munchies (frequently by Lake Arrowhead & Shore Dr.)
Serving inventive takes on classic beach fare, Murphy’s is famous for its loaded fries, gourmet grilled cheeses, and spicy shrimp tacos. The food is fun, affordable, and perfect for a quick bite between surf sessions.
- Sweet Carolina Shave Ice (makes the rounds near beach accesses)
Nothing says summer like a mound of fresh shave ice, and Sweet Carolina brings a rainbow of refreshing flavors to the neighborhood, especially during festivals and warm weekends.
Local Flavor: Neighborhood Traditions
No Long Bay visit is complete without a taste of these local traditions:
- Lowcountry Boil Nights at Bimini’s—piles of shrimp, sausage, corn, and potatoes, served family-style.
- Sunset Seafood Picnics on Shore Drive—locals grab takeout and stake out a spot on the dunes to watch the sun set over the Atlantic.
- Fall Oyster Roasts at neighborhood parks—bring your own gloves and hot sauce, and feast on just-steamed oysters with new friends.
Hidden Gems Worth Seeking Out
- Bay Naturals Kitchen & Market (7611 N. Kings Hwy.)
For those seeking veggie-friendly or gluten-free bites, Bay Naturals offers fresh sandwiches, hearty soups, and a juice bar. The vibe is earthy and health-focused, making it a unique contrast to the typical Southern fare found elsewhere.
- Blueberry’s Grill (7931 N. Kings Hwy., just north of Long Bay)
While technically a touch outside central Long Bay, foodies flock here for creative brunches—think blueberry hush puppies, home fries, and crab cake benedicts. Arrive early on weekends; it’s popular with in-the-know locals.
Tips for Food Lovers Exploring Long Bay
- Consider timing your visit for weekday evenings for lighter crowds and occasional live music.
- Many local restaurants and food trucks advertise daily specials on social media—follow for secret menu items!
- Ask what’s fresh or local—many places feature fish caught the same day or produce sourced from Horry County farms.
Long Bay may fly a bit under the radar compared to Myrtle Beach’s tourist hot spots, but its dining scene is imaginative, welcoming, and always satisfying—no matter your taste or budget. Next time you’re hungry, skip the chains and let Long Bay surprise you with a meal (or three!) you’ll be talking about long after you leave the coast.